Administrative Costs and the Organization of Individual Retirement Account Systems : A Comparative Perspective — page 1

Page 1 of 80 · Preview

Administrative Costs and the Organization of Individual Retirement Account Systems : A Comparative Perspective — page 2

Page 2 of 80 · Preview

Administrative Costs and the Organization of Individual Retirement Account Systems : A Comparative Perspective — page 3

Page 3 of 80 · Preview

Administrative Costs and the Organization of Individual Retirement Account Systems : A Comparative Perspective — page 4

Page 4 of 80 · Preview

Administrative Costs and the Organization of Individual Retirement Account Systems : A Comparative Perspective — page 5

Page 5 of 80 · Preview

Administrative Costs and the Organization of Individual Retirement Account Systems : A Comparative Perspective — page 6

🛡

You have reached the preview limit

The free preview includes the first 6 pages of 80. Download the original document to read the full content.

⬇ Download document

Page 6 of 80 · End of preview

The full document has 80 pages. Downloads happen on the original source site.

Administrative Costs and the Organization of Individual Retirement Account Systems : A Comparative Perspective

World Bank, Washington, DC

🛡CC BY 3.0 IGOPermitted use with attribution

pages: 80
Format: PDF
Size: 3.6 MB
Views: 0
Downloads: 0

↗Will open at the source site: World Bank Open Knowledge Repository

Source: World Bank Open Knowledge Repository ↗ · Report an issue

Shared byTanvi Menon›

Abstract

What is the most cost-effective way to organize individual accounts that are part of a mandatory social security system? Defined-contribution individual account components of social security systems are criticized for being too expensive. The authors investigate the cost-effectiveness of two methods for constructing mandatory individual accounts: a) Investing through the retail market with relatively open choice among investment companies (the method first used by Chile and adopted by most Latin American countries). b) Investing through the institutional market with constrained choice. For the retail market, they use data from mandatory pension funds in Chile and other Latin American countries and from voluntary mutual funds in the United States. For the institutional market, they use data from systems in Bolivia and Sweden and from larger pension plans and the federal Thrift Saving Plan in the United States. The institutional approaches aggregate numerous small accounts into large blocks of money and negotiate fees on a centralized basis, often through competitive bidding. They retain workers' choice o some funds. Fees and costs are kept low by reducing incentives for marketing, avoiding excess capacity at system start-up, and constraining choice to investment portfolio that are inexpensive to manage. In developed financial markets, the biggest potential cost saving stems from constrained portfolio choice, especially from a concentration on passive investment. The biggest cost saving for a given portfolio and for countries with weak financial markets comes from reduced marketing activities. In the retail market, where annualized fees and costs range from 0.8 percent to 1.5 percent of assets, use of the institutional market in individual retirement account systems has reduced those fees and costs to less than 0.2 percent to 0.6 percent of assets. This reduction can increase pensions by 10 - 20 percent relative to the retail market. Countries that can surmount rebidding problems, weaker performance incentives, inflexibility in the face of unforeseen contingencies, and an increased probability of corruption, collusion, and regulatory capture should seriously consider the institutional approach, especially at the start-up of a new multipillar system or for systems with small asset bases.

Related documents

Participation in WTO Dispute Settlement : Complainants, Interested Parties, and Free Riders

Moving Forward from Singapore

Malawi : Public Expenditure Review 2006

The Effects of Rice Export Policy on Regional Income, Prices and the Poor

Africa's Macroeconomic Story

Doing Business Economy Profile 2017